Chris
I cannot agree with you more. Wife and I have had cattle dogs for near 30 years. The thing about a cattle dog ( the appealing bit) is that they are like a mini with a V8 engine, their strength and "heart" vastly exceeds what you would expect from a small to medium sized dog. They are also very intelligent, fiercely loyal, implacable guard dogs and, to top it all off, they are as cute as a button.
But (and this is the unappealing or down side) they are working dogs, and if they do no thave work, they get up to mischief, they are also stubborn as little pigs and given half a chance they "bully" their human owners to become head dog in the pack. Lastly as a by-product of their breeding they can be more than a little OCD and you have to be ruthless in extinguishing OCD behaviour. Let's face it, their "job" in real life is to run into mobs of wild cattle and nip, bite and bark to control them, and to do it all day every day on low maintainence, they are tough little buggers.
For all the stuff in the second paragraph they are not appropriate dogs for 99% of people, you have to have time to "work" them, give the lots of play time and most of all you have to spend time training them. There was a fad in this country a few years back and Blue/Red cattle dogs were the affluent pet of choice - lots of dog attacks, lots of people scared of cattle dogs.
Our opinion is that they are only just capable of being kept in a "standard" suburban lot and then only with lots of training, lots of exercise and very strong limit setting.
Here is a really good example of strongly enforced limits.
(The caption in this when I originally posted it was "We were wolves once, wild and wary, stealth and cunning. Then we noticed you had sofas".)
And a quick second photo of Rosie in a boat. 5 minutes before she had never seen a boat and for that matter had never been surrounded by water, two circumstances that can reduce a strong dog to a howling wreck. Rosie, with typical cattle dog pragmatism decided "this is where my humans are, they aren't worried, so why should I be, but I'll just let everyone know I am on duty with the cattle dog glint".
Finally, aside from some dogs that as a result of catastrophic in-breeding are complete nutbags there is no such thing as a "dangerous" dog, there are merely humans who should not own dogs..