While my bezel didn't come out of surgery looking "factory," it did survive the rigors or opening and closing... twice (i forgot the seal the first time). The back of the bezel (which you pry and peen) pulls the front of the bezel against the seal and the lip of the gauge. Thus, the sealing surface won't get distorted unless you really start hammering on the thing. A good downward pressure on the back of the gauge should help keep things lined up and flat on the face.
I think I might have cut a hole in a 3/4" board with a hole saw while peening the bezel back over to act as a rough jig. I can't remember exactly, but it worked out well and I have no condensation in the gauge.
As a side note, I bet a bezel could be machined as a stepped ring, using set screws or a second clamping ring to provide enough even pressure for a good seal.