I like the aluminum one. I would do an oil change, fill with the right amount of oil, run the bike a bit, let it cool, and check the oil level with the new stick. If it's at the full mark you're fine, and can probably let it drop down some in between changes.
Is it just me, or is 2.5 quarts a fairly small quantity of oil for a 650 cc motor with a 5,000 mile change interval?