A small update: Took it to the local neighborhood moto shop (directly across the street from Iron Horse BMW) for a look-see. At first spin on the balance rig, the mechanic said the rim was fine and the tire looked fine, but it was WAY out of balance and the bearings were rough. Guess my ghetto balancing wasn't that good, eh?
Of course, they didn't stock the correct sized bearings, so I ran across the street (literally) to Iron Horse, and bought new front wheel bearings. After picking my jaw up off the floor from paying $84 for the bearings, (they didn't even have the seals in stock) I delivered them and left the mechanic to do his thing.
I don't have any experience with other tires other than the previous Kendas (which I grew to dislike) so I can't compare the Shinkos, but I've put about 200 miles on these so far. They feel confident, good grip, comfortable, don't track all over the road's cracks, etc. We'll see how long they last but I needed tires and with my pre-wedding budget they were too hard to pass up.