Hello,
These tachs use a circuit converting frequency to voltage.
As yours goes strait to 4500 RPM, no external reason for this because if the engine is not running, no alternating current is present in the whole machine.
So you have a short somewhere in the tach feeding some voltage to the meter, thus making it to move to 4500 RPM.
Check the printer circuit for a blob of solder and/or a seized meter wire which got deteriorated and make contact somewhere it should not...
If you do not find the fault, as these tachs are almost indestructible, they are plentiful on the second hand marked and do not ask for premium prices. So , change it. Just my 2 ?