Second what Adrian said.
I loathe physical effort and have tried every lotion and potion known to man in an attempt to improve the look of my engine case, gearbox and final drive.
I report 100% failure.
Obviously the "gold standard" is soda or vapour blasting, but that isn't possible on an assembled component. The only two things I have found to work are :
1/. Scotchbrite (green) and WD-40
2/. Paint (either Wurth silver wheel paint or Krylon "dull
aluminium")
There is one other I'll mention in passing which I know works absolutely brilliantly but which is simply not available to we mere mortals. A German company called Henkel makes a number of Aluminium "washes" in a variety of colours - you will most likely find it in use at your local brake rebuilder, he will use it to restore the blue/gold/silver/red colour of brake calipers.
It works brilliantly and is very simple, clean and degrease the part, wash in solution "A", then wash in solution "B" - job done.
Now, here is the rub. The chemicals used are classified as "dangerous goods" and a 5lt kit costs in excess of $AU300.
Talk to your local brake rebuilder you never know... I asked mine and he wasn't interested.