Thanks for the replies and as always, as in most forums, lots of differing opinions.
I'm leaning toward gloss black mainly because of the Gulf Coast environment it will be living in. Just easier to keep clean and to shed the salt air/vapor mix. But I am going to shoot a few places with satin to see how that looks first. I really can' tell what the factory did 30 years ago because everything is dulled, rusty or faded.
Dovetailing on that, the front forks were painted black from the boots down and up to the tree. When I power washed them, most of the paint came off exposing somewhat oxidized aluminum. I will finish the stripping of the paint with chemicals and elbow grease, clean the aluminum and then evaluate weather to repaint or polish.
Any thoughts? I'm not hung up on total originality. I'm even thinking about changing from the Polaris Silver body to black or Alfa Romeo red to match my car....