Ill give the front brake a chance to redeem its self. It has a very firm feel. I guess I was expecting it to be really grabby because of that. When I gave it a pull like I normally would on my HD it felt like the caliper was made of ice. But, in fairness there are a few factors that may be affecting that. First, I had a bit of overspray on the disk from painting the edge of the disk black, like it originally was. Second, during the rebuild I may have swapped the sides the pads came out of. I dont remember if they only go in one way. So they probably need to bed in. Also, my mechanic friend says I should sand them down a bit because they would be somewhat glazed after sitting for so long. Im not sure if I believe that, but it cant hurt to sand them down a little anyway. Lastly, I very well could have gotten a larger master cylinder. I was getting a bit desperate to source a new one and I relied on the parts guy to get the right one. I think it was Capitol Cycle. Seems BMW sort of gave up making parts for the single front brake system. A single brake line from the master to the caliper is non-existent from what I can tell. I had a custom one made from a local hydraulic and brake supply shop.
So, Im not bashing the front brake. Ive only logged about 3 miles going around and around my block (I think some neighbors were wondering what the heck I was doing). It just wasnt what I was expecting is all.