The New And Improved Unofficial R65 Forum V2
Technical Discussion => BMW Technical Q&A, Primarily R65 => Topic started by: Crossrodes on August 17, 2014, 07:42:20 PM
-
My '79 R65 wouldn't start this morning. So I checked the battery. It was dead. It is a sealed Odyssey battery which I think is a pretty good battery. It is 6 years old so it is probably at end of life (currently I am recharging it and will test it to see how long it will hold the charge). But I'm guessing it is toast.
I dug through my records and found I paid $168 (Canadian) for this battery. It has been a pretty good battery but it was very expensive.
So what make/model of battery is recommended these days for the R65?
Mike
-
I don't know if these companies ship to Canada or not .
http://www.gruberpower.com/12-volt-18-amp-hour-ah-battery
http://www.staabbattery.com/product/UB12220-V.html
Currently out of stock at radio Shack .
http://www.radioshack.com/product/index.jsp?productId=11909407
All of these are AGM type batteries .
-
Given the high price I would be unhappy at an Odyssey lasting only 6 years in a moderate climate. there is always a risk of premature failure and for that reason I would not buy a battery in that price range.
I recently bought a new battery and the way I saw it there were 2 options:
Buy a quality wet cell at 60-70% of the cost of an Odyssey. In a moderate climate it will last 10 years with ease if properly maintained and charged but the looking after does get tedious especially towards the end of it's life. I don't think it's an exaggeration to say 9 out 10 owner don't maintain wet cells properly and so don't get the service life they are capable of.
Buy a cheap generic AGM of the type Bob mentions which will owe you nothing if it lasts only 3 years. Compared to even a new wet cell the ability of an AGM to hold it's charge will be a revelation and if the bike is used regularly maintenance will be zero.
I chose a cheap generic Ultramax SLAUMXNPG20-12 AGM/Gel battery available in the UK and have been very pleased so far. I particular like the top mounting terminals which are so easy to access. Only negative point is the terminals are not shielded against inadvertent short circuit.
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/12V-20AH-Replace-17AH-18AH-19AH-21AH-22AH-ULTRA-MAX-NPG20-12-GEL-Battery-/131100536915?pt=UK_Health_Beauty_Mobility_Disability_Medical_ET&hash=item1e86337053
-
Thank you both for the info.
Barry, it has been my experience that a battery will usually last about 5 years. I do live in a mild climate and I do look after the batteries. If I don't use the bike for a couple of weeks I put the battery on a charger.
Right now I have been charging the battery for about 30 hours (2 amp charger). Originally it was sitting at about 3 volts. It is now up to 12 volts and still charging. Once I get it fully charged I will let it sit and see if it holds the charge. I am also wondering if I have a short in a circuit on the bike that could have caused it to discharge to that low a voltage. So I'll have to check out the circuits too. The other possibility is that the alternator is not working but I don't know how the battery would get as low as 3 volts and the bike not quit if the alternator failed. I'll check it out too.
-
At six years in service, the most likely cause, is an internal failure of the battery .
My last Odyssey battery only lasted 28 months, that's when I went to the generic AGM batteries .
-
I don't know how the battery would get as low as 3 volts and the bike not quit if the alternator failed.I'll check it out too.
A wet cell is considered fully discharged at 10.8 volts. For an AGM like the Odyssey it will be a little higher in the low to mid 11's. There is no way it could have run the bike like that and it couldn't have got down to 3 volts purely from normal internal self discharge so it must either have developed a fault or as you say maybe a permanent current draw.
-
Update....Well I charged the battery to 12.4 volts. I thought it would charge up to 12.8 but no. Anyway the battery seems to be holding the charge as I let it sit out of the bike for about 12 hours and it is still at 12.4.
So I started checking out the circuits on the bike. When I checked between the large positive cable which runs from the battery and ground it measured approximately 1.5 Ohms. So I'm guessing that I have a component failure there somewhere. So now I'm going to see if I can find the cause.
-
So I started checking out the circuits on the bike.When I checked between the large positive cable which runs from the battery and ground it measured approximately 1.5 Ohms.So I'm guessing that I have a component failure there somewhere.So now I'm going to see if I can find the cause.
That's some current draw. It would have the battery flat in no time. Diode board could be a suspect.
-
Barry that's what I'm thinking. I'm in the process of opening up the bike so that I can check things out.
-
Well I have finally done some more work on the bike. I removed the top engine cover and the cover for the air cleaner. And now my short has disappeared. I have checked out the cable from the battery (it goes to the starter motor) and see no wear that could cause a short. There is also a wire that goes from this cable to the diode board. Is it possible that I have a short on the board that disappeared because I was shaking things when I was removing the covers?
-
Is it possible that I have a short on the board that disappeared because I was shaking things when I was removing the covers?
Doesn't seem likely if it was a component failure on the diode board. Once diodes fail they don't repair themselves. If it's something to do with the diode board mounting then maybe.